Forsters acts for successful leaseholder in landmark Centre Point House Court of Appeal ruling
Forsters is delighted to have acted for one of the successful Respondent leaseholders in Almacantar v De Valk and others (“Centre Point House”), an important Court of Appeal decision handed down today.
The appeal concerned the leaseholder protections in the Building Safety Act 2022 and asked the Court to grapple with some fundamental questions about paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the Act: does it protect qualifying leaseholders against cladding remediation costs only if there is a statutory “relevant defect”, and how widely should the concepts of “cladding”, a “cladding system” and “unsafe” be interpreted?
In a unanimous decision handed down by LJJ Fancourt, Newey and Miles, the Court of Appeal has decided that the language of paragraph 8 is clear – there is no reference to “relevant defect” as a pre-condition for the protection to apply, and no basis to read one in as a matter of statutory interpretation. On the meaning of “cladding” and “cladding system”, the Court was clear that this was a matter of fact for the First-tier Tribunal to decide, having had the benefit of detailed expert and factual evidence, as well as a site visit, but that the outer wall at Centre Point House was entitled to be considered within the meaning of “cladding system”. There was nothing in the FTT’s or Upper Tribunal’s decision to indicate that they had erred. Finally, the meaning of “unsafe” cannot be confined purely to fire safety defects (as Almacantar had contended) but rather given its ordinary meaning of posing a danger. In the case of Centre Point House itself, this means that a rotting façade which had become structurally unsafe due to water ingress was within the meaning of paragraph 8.
The judgment is another example of the purposive approach being given by the courts and tribunals to the Building Safety Act 2022, a groundbreaking piece of legislation. Whilst a statutory intervention of this magnitude will inevitably give rise to cases that fall foul of the ‘bright line’, the reason for the intervention, and the numerous comments made by Government when promoting the Bill, make clear that improving safety standards, and financial protection for ordinary people living in their homes, was paramount.
Although the cladding design at Centre Point House is unique, the case could have implications for other types of unusual cladding, or cladding which is found to be unsafe for reasons other than fire risk. Importantly, it also shows that the 30 year backwards limitation period does not apply to cladding remediation when it comes to passing on costs through the service charge.
Forsters has acted in this dispute since the proceedings began in the First-tier Tribunal and has remained involved through the Upper Tribunal and Court of Appeal. We are very proud to have supported our client throughout this long-running dispute. The Forsters team is led by Julia Tobbell, Partner in the Real Estate Disputes team, supported by Senior Associate Emma Gregory.

